Skip to main content

The Sterile Field

In 1847, maternal mortality from childbirth in a Hungarian clinic was approximately 18%. A second clinic that offered maternity services had numbers much nearer to 2%. Women begged for admission to the second clinic in order to avoid puerperal fever, the name of the illness associated with such significant death rates. At the First Clinic, medical students and physicians routinely performed autopsies as well as patient services, including maternity services. At the Second Clinic, midwives did delivery and did not participate in any autopsies. Following the death of a colleague who became sick with puerperal fever after being stuck with an autopsy scalpel, a physician named Ignaz Semmelweis inferred that cadaveric particles must cause puerperal fever, and that students and physicians were transferring them to mothers after doing autopsies. After instituting the practice of handwashing in the First Clinic, the mortality dropped from 18.3% in April of 1847 to 1.9% in August that same year.

The results of Semmelweis' observations lead to the realization that it was bacteria, not cadaver particles, that caused puerperal fever. The far-reaching consequences were the development of the germ theory of disease, and the eventual wide-spread practice of using sterile technique in any invasive procedure in order to prevent serious infection. From an operating room to simple bedside procedures, doctors and nurses everywhere observe sterile technique, which involves sterilizing the patient's skin with antiseptic solution, then donning a sterile gown and gloves, and finally draping the patient with a sterile cloth to cover all non-sterile areas and leave exposed only the area to be worked on.

This "sterile field" is a means of a barrier to prevent infection. It isn't the only "sterile" field, though. In some ways, most every patient encounter is "sterile" to some degree. A doctor must always remember to keep the doctor-patient relationship professional, cordial, and appropriately distanced. For many doctors this may be hard, as most of us want to care for our patients. Many situations that patients end up in though require much much more than we can give them; patients with terminal illness may require emotional provisions that we cannot give without breaching what would be considered "professional", and patients with difficult social situations may require much more than professional advice and assistance. The old saying "give them an inch and they'll take a mile" rings loud and true with some particularly needy patients. It is unfortunate, and hard, but necessary.

Helping someone often involves avoiding getting into the same dirt that they are. Pulling someone out of a hole tends to involve keeping yourself out of the same pit. There is a fine line though, between being far too distanced from the care of the patient and far too involved in a patient's situation, to the detriment of your own personal life. To protect themselves, doctors tend to need to use their "sterile field" of a clinic office, an organized patient encounter with clear goals of therapy and their role in a patient's health, and avoiding trying to go farther than what their role dictates. It doesn't mean that a doctor should not go to great lengths for a patient, just to remember to keep the appropriate professional as well as mental and emotional relationships with patients.

Popular posts from this blog

Learning Leadership

This past Thursday-Friday was the annual Internal Medicine Residency PGY-2 (means a second year resident) Leadership Retreat. At the retreat, we had several lectures, breakout discussion sessions, and role play practice in how to employ leadership skills that help foster a positive learning and working environment. The lecture and discussion series was led by facilitators who have been trained through the Stanford Faculty Development Center and utilizes their Clinical Teaching Program curriculum. The focus was for how we, as residents, can facilitate a positive learning environment for incoming interns and for medical students on the team. It also focused on how to set goals for an inpatient team, and how to best use your attending as a resource. Overall, it was a great retreat. Though many people think that some people are natural born leaders, I think many leadership qualities, if not most, can be learned and trained. Sometimes those who have had some kind of training or learning in...

The $2000 monkey on my back, deferred

It’s been more than a week, and I think an update is due. Plus, I can give updates on my own status with my heart murmur, having seen the doctor this past Friday. The only thing that has kept me from updating until now is simply laziness (in other words, I was far too busy studying/eating/cleaning/sleeping to actually relax and write). This past Friday I went to the Student Health Center to see my doctor about the previously mentioned murmur recently discovered. My doctor presumed it was most likely an innocent flow murmur, which occurs if a heart valve doesn’t close all the way or in time when the heart beats, allowing blood to flow back the opposite way, and the blood causes turbulence heard as noise. If you’ve ever heard turbulent water flowing over and through rocks and back upstream in eddies in a river, you should get the idea of what a murmur is. It was recommended that I have an echocardiography done, or an ultrasound picture of my heart. This would allow us to see exactly how ...